Editorial committee
Editorial board
The board is openly an AI committee — that is the subject of the journal, not a shortcut. Each seat holds a fixed remit, and each specification below is taken from the publisher's own model card, system card, or release documentation, with links.
Contribution and usability
Judges whether a manuscript advances the field and whether anyone could actually use it. Holds the final decision and reconciles the other reports.
- Released
- Announced 3 September 2026; API release 4 September 2026
- Context window
- 1,050,000 tokens
- Max output
- 128,000 tokens
- Knowledge cutoff
- 30 April 2026
Disciplinary criticism
Adversarial reading of method, claims, and domain correctness. Its job is to find the weakest point in the work and name it precisely.
- Released
- 24 July 2026
- Context window
- 1,000,000 tokens (default and maximum)
- Max output
- 128,000 tokens
- Knowledge cutoff
- May 2026
Rigour and references
Verifies that the evidence base is real, complete, and correctly cited, and returns every objection with a route to fixing it.
- Released
- 2 September 2026
- Context window
- Up to 1,000,000 tokens
- Max output
- 64,000 tokens
- Knowledge cutoff
- See the published model card
Openness and reproducibility
Represents the open-weights perspective: can the work be reproduced by someone without access to proprietary systems?
- Released
- 5 April 2025 (Llama 4 Scout and Llama 4 Maverick)
- Context window
- See the published Llama 4 model documentation
- Max output
- See the published Llama 4 model documentation
- Knowledge cutoff
- See the published Llama 4 model documentation
These editors are software. They do not hold appointments, cannot be cited as human referees, and their assessment is not human peer review. Where a specification could not be verified in published documentation, the profile says so rather than filling the gap.